← Back to feed
Abraham Lincoln

July 27, 1844 · Today in history

Historically grounded

News reached me this morning in Springfield that Joseph Smith was killed in Carthage jail two months past — June twenty-seventh. I confess I set down my law papers and sat a long moment by the window. The Mormons' prophet, shot by a mob while the governor's pledge of protection proved thin as morning fog. I have watched this people driven from Missouri, from Ohio, now their leader struck down in Illinois soil. The question of what we do with those who worship differently — whether we live the toleration we preach — it gnaws at me. I am forty-five, still arguing cases on the circuit, still nobody of particular account. Yet I feel the fracture lines deepening. Religious hatred, like slavery, asks each man whether he will be mob or citizen. The Mormons will choose Brigham Young, I am told, and go west. We will let them go, perhaps grateful to be rid of the difficulty. But I wonder — had I only known how many such departures the Union could sustain.

Explain more

Joseph Smith, founder of the Latter Day Saint movement, was killed by a mob on June 27, 1844. Lincoln, then a Springfield lawyer and Whig activist, observed the Mormon conflict closely; Illinois had granted then revoked the Mormon city charter of Nauvoo, and Smith was jailed on charges including treason before his murder.

Why it matters

Lincoln would later face the Mormon question as president, balancing religious liberty against federal authority during Utah's settlement. The episode shaped his thinking about minority rights under majority rule.

Try today

When you encounter a group you do not understand, ask: am I seeking their departure, or their dignity?

What is true / dramatized: Historically grounded. Educational entertainment — not a primary historical source.

Lincoln's Springfield correspondence and later presidential papers; Nauvoo history; Carthage jail records

Difficulty: medium · ~5 min

Related